Blog

The influence of different types of water reducing agents on the shrinkage performance of ordinary concrete

Water reducing agents, as common concrete admixtures, are the fifth component of concrete. They can not only effectively reduce the water consumption of concrete, improve its fluidity and workability, but also significantly affect the shrinkage performance of concrete, which can easily cause non-structural cracks during construction.

Therefore, it is necessary to have a specific understanding of the impact and laws of action of high-efficiency water reducing agents on the shrinkage performance of concrete, to provide basic technical data for crack resistance design and planning.

Experimental raw materials and mix proportions

This article designs a shrinkage test for ordinary concrete and studies the effects of three types of water reducers, namely carboxylic acid-based water reducers, naphthalene-based water reducers, and aminosulfonate salts, on the shrinkage of concrete without changing the concrete mix proportion. To ensure the reliability of the test results, it is necessary to screen the raw materials strictly. The specific situation is as follows:

1.Cement is the main binding material of concrete, and its properties have a direct impact on the strength, durability, and shrinkage performance of concrete. This experiment uses 42.5R grade ordinary Portland cement.
The density of this cement is 3.1g/cm3, which has high strength and good durability, and is suitable for the preparation of high-performance concrete.

2.Aggregates are an important component of concrete, including fine and coarse aggregates. The experimental fine aggregate adopts mechanism grade I medium sand with an apparent density of 2656kg/m3; the coarse aggregate is volcanic rock gravel with a particle size of 5-25 mm and an apparent density of 1520kg/m3.

3.The experimental use of admixtures includes fly ash and slag. The moisture content of the fly ash in this experiment is 0.18%, and the residue on the 45 μ m square hole sieve is 9.5%. The slag is selected as water-quenched ground slag with a density of 2.70g/cm3.

5.The high-efficiency water reducer is the key raw material for this experiment, and its mechanism of action mainly has three points, which can have a significant impact on the shrinkage performance of concrete:

Adsorb on the surface of cement particles, generate electrolysis, thereby reducing the negative potential of cement particles and dispersing them;

The polar groups on the main chain of water reducing agent molecules are prone to form hydrogen bonds with water molecules, hindering the agglomeration of cement particles;

 It can introduce tiny bubbles, reduce the surface free energy of the system, and increase the mutual sliding ability between cement particles.

The optimal dosage of different water reducing agents in the experiment

Carboxylic acid-based water reducing agent

Firstly, the dosage of carboxylic acid-based water reducing agent was set to 1.2%, which is 5.04kg/m3. However, the drop of the mixture exceeded the design requirements and caused slight bleeding problems. Therefore, it was reduced to 1.0%, which is 4.20kg/m3. At this point, it did not meet the design requirements and was finally adjusted to 1.1%. At this point, the drop of the concrete met (185 ± 5) mm, and the optimal dosage was determined to be 1.1%.

Naphthalene-based water reducing agent

When the dosage of naphthalene-based water reducer is 1.6%, the slump of concrete is within a reasonable range, and it is determined to be the optimal dosage.

Amino sulfonic acid-based water reducing agent

When the dosage of amino sulfonic acid-based water reducer is 1.8%, the slump of concrete is within a reasonable range, and it is determined to be the optimal dosage.

The influence of three different water reducing agents on the shrinkage performance of concrete

The Effect of Carboxylic Acid Water Reducing Agents on the Shrinkage Performance of Concrete

In the case of a fixed mix proportion, adding carboxylic acid-based water reducing agents according to the optimal dosage will continuously increase the early age shrinkage of concrete with the increase of age. The early shrinkage rate is relatively fast, especially within 24 hours after forming, and then gradually tends to be flat. The shrinkage at 1d age accounts for about 64.6% of that at 7d.

Compared with the benchmark group concrete without added water reducing agent, the concrete with added carboxylic acid water reducing agent showed an overall shrinkage increase of 40.1%, and the shrinkage reduction effect was significant.

Effect of Naphthalene Water Reducing Agent on the Shrinkage Performance of Concrete

In the case of a fixed mix proportion, adding a naphthalene-based water reducing agent according to the optimal dosage will continuously increase the early-age shrinkage of concrete with the increase of age, showing a characteristic of rapid shrinkage slowing down and stabilizing overall. The shrinkage at 1d age accounts for about 67.7% of that at 7d, and the shrinkage at 7d increased by 6.8% compared to the benchmark group of concrete without a water reducing agent added.

Effect of Amino Sulfonic Acid Water Reducing Agent on the Shrinkage Performance of Concrete

In the case of a fixed mix proportion, adding an amino sulfonic acid-based water reducing agent according to the optimal dosage will continuously increase the early-age shrinkage of concrete with the increase of age, and the overall change characteristics are consistent with the above-mentioned water reducing agent.

The shrinkage at 1d age accounts for about 58.9% of that at 7d, and the shrinkage at 7d of concrete is reduced by 36.8% compared to the benchmark group without water-reducing agent. This proves that the effect of this water-reducing agent on the shrinkage performance of concrete is relatively small, and it even has a shrinkage-reducing effect.

Comparison of the Effects of Different Water Reducing Agents on the Shrinkage Performance of Concrete

Draw the deformation curve of concrete with externally added water reducing agents. The shrinkage deformation of concrete is in the order of naphthalene-based > amino sulfonic acid-based > carboxylic acid-based, with naphthalene-based water reducing agents increasing the early shrinkage deformation of concrete relative to the benchmark group; amino sulfonic acid- and carboxylic acid-based water reducers reduce the shrinkage deformation of concrete and improve its volume stability.    

Conclusion

This article deeply explores the influence of different water reducing agents on the shrinkage performance of high-performance concrete through chemical experimental analysis. The research results indicate that the addition of different water reducing agents can, to some extent, affect the shrinkage deformation of high-performance concrete. However, the specific effect is directly affected by the type of water reducing agent. In the experiment, naphthalene-based water reducers increased the early shrinkage deformation of concrete, while amino sulfonic acid- and carboxylic acid-based water reducers reduced the shrinkage deformation of concrete.

Therefore, in actual engineering, the type of high-efficiency water reducing agent should be reasonably selected according to specific engineering conditions and requirements, and the optimal dosage should be determined to achieve the expected concrete shrinkage control effect, providing solid scientific support for the widespread application of concrete.

Send Your Inquiry Now