Blog

Concrete retarding accidents caused by improper dosage of admixtures

Accident Overview

Concrete pouring for the five-story structural beams, slabs, and columns at the construction site began at 4:00 pm on August 21, 2017, and was completed around 1:00 am on August 22. At around 9:00 on August 22, construction workers reported that the last two trucks of concrete poured at that time did not set, resulting in delayed setting. Our company sent testing personnel to the site to inspect the situation. Other parts have already passed final setting, while the affected part is the last pour of the five-layer structural slab, which has a soft surface and can be clearly marked with footprints, indicating that the concrete has not yet set.

Cause of the accident

The laboratory, together with the production department, immediately organised personnel to verify the raw materials and production situation used at the project site, analyse the reasons for the prolonged concrete setting time, and take effective measures to address the delayed setting. From the production records, it was found that the departure time for this part of the concrete was 12 cubic meters for car 8 and 4 cubic meters for car 11 on August 22, 2013, at 0:13 and 01:02, respectively, totalling 16 cubic meters.

By checking the raw material test records, no abnormal situations were found. The cement P.O42.5 had an initial setting time of 223 minutes and a final setting time of 284 minutes; Fly ash: Grade II, with a water demand ratio of 99%; River sand, with a fineness modulus of 2.5 and a mud content of 3%; Gravel: 5- 25 mm; FDN high-efficiency retarder, water reducer, water reduction rate of 20%, dosage of 2.0%. The mix proportion of this project is as follows:

Raw materials

C

F

W

S

G

water reducer

Usage kg/m3

290

100

175

766

1050

7.8

By checking the raw material entry records and inquiring with the on-duty tester and host operator, it was found that a new truck of cement was added at 9:35 pm on August 21, sampled, and poured into tanks for direct use in production. During the production process, it was found that the water demand was too high, the slump was too low, and the loss was fast. The on-duty testing personnel increased the additive dosage to 2.2%, but the effect on slump retention was not significant. Feedback from the construction site showed that the concrete slump was too low and could not be used. Finally, a vehicle adjusted the admixture dosage to 2.5% for production, and the slump barely met the requirements.

Through investigation and analysis, it can be determined that the reason for the prolonged setting time of the concrete in this case is the poor compatibility between the newly added cement and admixtures, the excessive use of admixtures to meet workability requirements, and the fact that the nighttime temperature is much lower than the daytime temperature, resulting in the prolonged setting time of the concrete. Our company personnel have negotiated with the construction unit to strengthen the curing work of the uncondensed concrete and cover it.

Control of concrete setting time

After mixing commercial concrete with water, the slurry gradually loses its fluidity and plasticity due to cement hydration; this process is called concrete setting. To ensure sufficient time to complete concrete mixing, transportation, pouring, vibration, finishing, curing, and other processes, the setting time of concrete should not be too short. However, the setting time of concrete should not be too long, as it may affect subsequent construction processes. Generally, the initial setting time of concrete is controlled to 6-10 hours, and the final setting time is controlled to 10-14 hours.

Super retarding concrete refers to concrete that sets for more than 24 hours under normal conditions by adding retarders, which is considered accidental retarding. During the production of commercial concrete, due to changes in material properties or sudden changes in environmental temperature, as well as operational errors, non-setting for 24-36 hours or even 72 hours may occur.

Factors affecting the setting time of concrete

The influence of water-cement ratio on the setting time of concrete

Under the same experimental conditions, there is a good correlation between the setting time of concrete and the setting time of cement. Wang Shanba et al.’s experimental research suggests that the setting time of cement is usually determined at a water-cement ratio of 0.24 and 0.27, while the water-cement ratio of concrete with a strength grade of C30 is generally between 0.46 and 0.50. The water-cement ratio and setting time of the two are approximately the same.

Jiang Xiaoni and others’ experimental research suggests that the setting time of concrete increases as the water-cement ratio increases. For every 0.08 increase in water-cement ratio, the initial setting time of concrete increases by 24.4%, and the final setting time increases by 19.7%. When the water-cement ratio of concrete is high, the distance between cement particles is large. Therefore, a large amount of hydration products must be produced to enable the cement particles to overlap and grow together.

In addition, hydration products will form a thin film on the surface of cement particles, which hinders the contact between water and unhydrated cement. Water molecules must diffuse into the interior of cement particles through this thin film, so cement hydration is controlled by diffusion and the hydration rate slows down. Therefore, when the water-to-cement ratio is high, the hydration products between cement particles are less likely to overlap and coalesce, and the setting time becomes longer.

In addition, in cement slurry, the space between two cement particles is overlapped by the hydration products generated by the two cement particles, while in cement mortar, the space between one cement particle and one sand is filled by the hydration products generated by the cement particles, because the sand does not produce any hydration products. Therefore, the setting time of concrete is much longer than that of cement.

The influence of mineral admixtures on the setting time of concrete

The setting time of concrete mainly depends on cement setting to complete the hardening and shaping of the mixture. The four main mineral components of cement clinker, C3S, C2S, C3A, and C4AF, have a hydration rate of C3A>C4AF>C3S>C2S. The mineral admixtures mainly used in commercial concrete include fly ash and mineral powder. The main chemical components of fly ash are SiO2, Al2O3, and Fe2O3, which together account for more than 70% of the total content. The main chemical components of slag powder are CaO, SiO2, and Al2O3, with over 90% of its content comprising these three oxides.

The chemical composition of these mineral admixtures undergoes a secondary reaction with the hydration product Ca(OH)2 of cement to improve the later strength and compactness of concrete. In the initial stage of concrete hydration, it basically does not participate in the hydration reaction. Therefore, using mineral admixtures in the cementitious system reduces the relative content of C3A and C4AF in cement, which slows the hydration rate of C3A and C4AF. The setting time of concrete increases as mineral admixture content increases.

The influence of admixtures on the setting time of concrete

High-efficiency water reducers, or high-performance water reducers, are commonly used in commercial concrete. When water reducers are added, they adsorb onto the surface of cement particles during the early stages of cement hydration; On the one hand, in the alkaline medium of cement hydration, the active groups of water-reducing agent molecular chains (such as – COO -, – SO3-) form unstable complexes with ions generated by cement (such as calcium ions), delaying the progress of cement hydration. The higher the dosage, the longer the hydration inhibition time; therefore, macroscopically, the setting time of concrete increases with increasing dosage.

A concrete retarder is an additive that delays the cement hydration reaction, thereby prolonging the setting time of concrete. Generally speaking, retarders have surface activity. They adsorb at solid and liquid surfaces, alter the surface properties of solid particles, or form a water film layer by adsorbing a large number of water molecules through hydrophilic groups, hindering the hydration process and achieving a retarding effect. The larger the retarder dosage, the more pronounced the retarding effect. Relevant experiments have shown that when the dosage of sodium gluconate is in the range of 0.02% to 0.08%, the cement setting time is extended by about 100 minutes for every 0.02% increase in dosage.

For pumped commercial concrete or concrete constructed in high-temperature environments during summer, using a combination of retarders and high-efficiency water reducers is an effective method to prolong the setting time of concrete and reduce slump loss, ensuring normal concrete construction.

The influence of environmental temperature and humidity on the setting time of concrete

The environmental temperature has a significant impact on the hydration rate of cement. Cement hydrates faster at high temperatures and slower at low temperatures. When the temperature approaches 0 ℃, cement hydration stops. Changes in air humidity also affect the setting time of concrete, with high humidity causing a longer setting time and low humidity causing a shorter setting time.

Estimation of concrete setting time in this case

Assuming the external temperature is the same as the laboratory conditions, we can roughly estimate the concrete setting time in this case. The initial setting time of cement (T1) is 223 minutes, and the final setting time is 284 minutes. The water-cement ratio used to determine the cement setting time is 0.26; the water-cement ratio of the concrete mix is 0.45; the fly ash content is 25%; the admixture dosage is 2.5%; and the retarding component accounts for 3% of the total admixture dosage. The retarding component is 0.75% of the cementitious material dosage, which can extend the time by about 350 minutes. By rough estimation, the initial setting time for our mix ratio is about 11 hours, and the final setting time is about 14 hours.

Treatment plan for extended concrete time in this case

This concrete construction occurred in late August, during the direct summer season. The temperature was around 35 ℃ at noon, the air was dry, and the concrete’s setting time was short. To ensure normal construction, a large amount of retarding component was used in the admixture. The retarding component used in this batch of admixture was 0.6% of cement. At night, the temperature is around 20 ℃, and the air humidity is relatively high. When the additive dosage is high, the impact on the concrete’s setting time is more significant, which is also the main reason for the prolonged setting time of the last two trucks of concrete.

Based on the estimated setting time of this batch of concrete, it can be preliminarily inferred that the initial setting time is around 11 am and the final setting time is around 2 pm. Because the concrete has not yet set and lacks crack resistance, the surface is prone to plastic shrinkage cracks as it loses water. Negotiate with the construction unit to cover and cure the delayed concrete, and have the construction personnel closely monitor the concrete’s setting.

After observation, the concrete in this section finally set at 3:00 pm, with a total setting time of 15 hours. The setting time of the concrete was about 7 hours longer than in other parts. Due to the use of a thin film covering for curing, the concrete surface moisture did not dissipate, and no plastic shrinkage cracks were found. The concrete setting time is about 15 hours, which will not adversely affect the concrete’s later strength.

After 28 days of negotiation among the construction party, supervision unit, and commercial mixing enterprise, the local geological monitoring station will act as a third party to conduct quality inspection. After 28 days, the rebound test conducted by the quality supervision station testing personnel showed that the concrete strength in this test area was 37.7 MPa, while the concrete strength in the other two test areas poured in the same batch was 38.2 MPa and 37.9 MPa, and the strength was not affected.

Lessons Learned from Accidents

  1. Strengthen the quality control management of concrete production, and enhance the systems and methods for adjusting concrete mix proportions.
  2. Strengthen the compatibility testing of cement and admixtures, understand the basic performance of admixtures, avoid adjusting the workability of concrete solely by adjusting the dosage of admixtures, and prevent quality accidents caused by excessive use of admixtures.

Send Your Inquiry Now

EXPLORE OUR PRODUCT RANGE

PCE MONOMERS • PCE • SNF

Product information, specifications & applications — sent directly to your email.

*Your information is kept confidential and will only be used to contact you regarding our products.